take this off>>> Amr Khaled is not perfect but neither is the clip.... the boy does not say anything about amr khaled , doesn't even mention
him even indirectly, so how can you say he means to attack him because some smartie put a clip from Amr khaled in the middle of the speech. Besides this is a little boy. The words are memorized and it is not his own Ijtihad, he has many many years before he can speak about fiqh in a proper way. Besides what Amr khaled was saying in the clip in the middle was in reference to the khitaan and abuse of girls in Africa where this practice (female genital mutilation) is practiced savagely on girls of early age. Amr khaled is not a scholar and he is not perfect, but at least he goes out there and does some dawah in his own way, and that's what most people will not dare anyway. So give people credit , even if it's a minor thing, even if they said things before or after that are not proper. If a man speaks on an issue and he is right we can't just blindly say oh well Amr khaled is wrong because he's wrong in everything. And who ever put this clip on youtube is crazy. Most of the commenteries of people who watched the clip agree that it was fabricated in that it tried to fit the words of the child as a response to Amr khaled. Amr khaled is not a shaikh but he's a dayah. At last he speaks from his own knoweledge and hard work. The child has only memorized and been put on stage. That's fine also, but lets not mix two different clips that have nothing to do with each other to make a statement about someone like that.... to me that is a grave haram because you're putting some done by using someone else's words to intentionally misleed.... shame on the person who did that!!!!
Sir you have said that the child has memorized everything. that is impossible to a kid like that one... I'm really amazed by that kid..eventhough he memorized he would not speak like that. because he is speaking with out delays... And how could that be possible a young kid memorized a speach for more than half an hour and speaks without going back even one word..
I agree with you on most of it, but this part didn't fit into my brain..
thank you so much for this
ليش ايش قال عمرو خالد
لا حول ولا قوة الا بالله طفل لم يتجاوز التاسعه من العمر يصف شيخ له باع طويل في خدمة الاسلام
بأنه خبيث والله انه لتطاول سفيه يجب على الجميع أستنكاره ولأجل ماذا لاجل اشياء تافه
it is perfectly and scientifically possible to memorize a speech like that. If he was speaking of his own mind he WOULD have delays. But a memorized speech needs no delays. We have a a lot of kids who memorize more than 30 minute speeches and speak in public events (like the Yemeni thawrah holiday kid who can memorize huge gasida and say it perfect without flaw). Kids are like sponges (better than adults in this regard) and if you nurture them well they can learn to memorize and learn well. But memory is one thing and knwoledge that is linked to exeprience and a long life of study is a totally different thing.
أعان الله عمروا خالد....آمين
انا استغرب..... في بداية الفلم تضن ان الاستاذ عمروا خالد قد اصاب اثم ... لكن لما تشاهد آخر الفلم وكلام عمروا خالد بنفسه .... تستغرب من الغيرة على عمروا خالد!!!!!!!!!!!
المفروض الكل يقدم ما عنده لخدمة الامه .
لكن الملاحظ ناس يعملوا وناس ينتقدوا.لكن الصراحه الاستاذ عمرو خالد والدكتور طارق السويدان هامات عاليه رغم التطاول عليهم في كل مكان الجماعه شغالين ولايلتفتوا لهذه التفاهات.
أفصل بين الأسماء بفاصلة.